Naperville vs. Other Chicago Suburbs: Which One is Best?

Choosing the Best Chicago Suburb: How Does Naperville Compare?

If you're considering a move to the Chicago suburbs, Naperville is likely on your shortlist. But how does it stack up against nearby cities like Aurora, Oswego, Plainfield, and Geneva? Each suburb has its own unique character, home prices, school systems, and amenities, making the choice highly personal. Whether you’re prioritizing schools, affordability, commuting, or lifestyle, this guide will help you decide which suburb is the best fit for you.

Naperville vs. Aurora: Schools, Safety, and Affordability

Naperville and Aurora are neighboring suburbs, but they differ significantly in terms of home values, school rankings, and overall atmosphere.

Home Prices & Cost of Living

Naperville has a higher median home price, with single-family homes typically starting around $450,000, whereas Aurora offers a more affordable market with homes starting closer to $250,000-$350,000.

• Naperville: Higher property taxes but larger homes, more modern subdivisions, and better resale value.

• Aurora: More affordable housing options, including historic homes, newer developments, and condos.

Schools & Safety

Naperville is home to top-ranked District 203 and District 204 schools, consistently ranked among the best in Illinois. Aurora has a mix of strong schools in the western and southern parts of the city, while some areas struggle with lower performance ratings.

• Naperville: Top-tier public schools, low crime rates, strong community involvement.

• Aurora: Some high-performing schools, but rankings are more varied depending on the district.

Learn More About Naperville’s Schools

Naperville vs. Oswego: Suburban Growth & Affordability

Oswego is a rapidly growing suburb that offers more affordable housing and a small-town feel, making it an attractive alternative to Naperville.

Housing & Home Prices

Naperville’s real estate is well-established, with many historic and luxury homes. Oswego, on the other hand, features newer subdivisions with modern layouts at lower prices.

• Naperville: Higher cost, more amenities, and a mix of historic homes and new developments.

• Oswego: More affordable homes, many new construction neighborhoods, lower property taxes.

Lifestyle & Amenities

Naperville boasts a thriving downtown with top-tier dining, entertainment, and boutique shopping. Oswego has a charming downtown, but it's more spread out and suburban.

• Naperville: Bustling nightlife, restaurants, shopping, and events like Ribfest.

• Oswego: Smaller downtown, but still offers local breweries, parks, and community events.

Explore Moving to Oswego

Naperville vs. Plainfield: Commuting & Family Living

Plainfield is another popular choice for families looking for larger homes at lower prices while still being close to Naperville.

Home Prices & Space

If you want more house for your money, Plainfield is a strong contender. New construction homes in Plainfield often start around $375,000, while comparable homes in Naperville could be closer to $500,000+.

• Naperville: More established neighborhoods, larger lot sizes in some areas.

• Plainfield: Growing suburban area, newer developments, lower cost of living.

Commute & Accessibility

Naperville offers multiple Metra train stations for easy commuting to Chicago, while Plainfield commuters often rely on I-55 and Route 59.

• Naperville: Ideal for commuters with train access and multiple highways.

• Plainfield: Great for drivers but lacks direct public transit options to Chicago.

Compare Naperville and Plainfield Real Estate

Naperville vs. Geneva: Small-Town Charm vs. Bustling Suburb

If you’re drawn to charming downtown areas with historic appeal, Geneva might be a contender against Naperville.

Lifestyle & Community

Geneva is known for its quaint downtown, local boutiques, and riverfront scenery, while Naperville is larger and more dynamic.

• Naperville: Larger city feel, wider variety of restaurants and activities.

• Geneva: Quiet, picturesque setting, more historic buildings and small-town charm.

Housing & Schools

Geneva’s housing market includes historic homes and newer luxury developments, but its smaller size means fewer housing options compared to Naperville’s vast real estate market.

• Naperville: Larger selection of homes, highly rated schools.

• Geneva: More intimate feel, great schools but fewer choices.

Find Out If Geneva Is Right for You

Which Suburb is Best for You?

Your ideal Chicago suburb depends on your priorities. If you want top-rated schools, vibrant city amenities, and strong real estate values, Naperville is a clear winner. However, if you’re looking for affordability, a quieter setting, or easier commuting options, suburbs like Aurora, Oswego, Plainfield, and Geneva all have unique advantages.

Still unsure? Contact me today for a personalized consultation to find the perfect Chicago suburb for you!